Standard setting by the PCAOB was traditionally an exception to this approach. In 2018, we issued a Strategic Plan that promised innovative oversight, including with respect to our approach to writing auditing standards. In our Concept Release published in December 2019, we suggested that firms’ QC systems could have as an objective conformity with our existing standards. The SEC, which oversees the PCAOB, swore Zietsman in virtually. The guide contains marked text illustrations of the amendments in Release 2020-003, Amendments to PCAOB Interim Independence Standards and PCAOB Rules to Align with Amendments to Rule 2-01 of Regulation S-X , published on November 19. An expediency, the decision was accompanied by a commitment to reexamine the standards “as soon as possible”. As a result of strong investor interest, participation and feedback, these matters were added to the standard-setting agenda and ultimately adopted by the prior Board. Moreover, their removal and relegation to a status of “monitor[ing] relevant developments” is problematic in light of the particular importance of these areas in an economic environment deeply impacted by the continuing pandemic. These standards were written by the audit profession during the era of self-regulation, with little input from the public and were sharply criticized during Congressional hearings. Her term will run through October 2025. The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board is proposing a new auditing standard that relates to the auditor’s evaluation of a company’s relationships and transactions with related parties, and amendments to existing auditing standards that relate to significant unusual transactions and financial relationships and transactions by a company with its executive officers (including incentive … It provides users with an overview of the amended standard and a tutorial on how to navigate to the new standards on the PCAOB website. On November 20, the PCAOB announced the swearing in of Megan Zietsman, the board’s chief auditor and director of professional standards since early 2019, as a board member. Nor have they had an opportunity to address whether the PCAOB should emphasize the standard-setting priorities of an international body rather than the priorities that they recommended. The failure to modernize the “interim” independence standards and the related ethics rules gives new meaning to the term “interim” as the PCAOB approaches the beginning of the 18 th year of these “interim” requirements. Were we to take these steps, the standard-setting and research priorities would likely be very different and better suited to the needs of investors and other participants in the capital markets. It will provide an overview of the rulemaking on auditing estimates and highlight aspects of the new requirements. Neither group has had an opportunity to publicly weigh in on the decisions to remove from the agendas the very projects that they asked us to include. “As business changes in certain companies, [and there are] changes in company processes and controls, including IT controls, perhaps new … Informing your decision-making. Required fields are marked *, You may use these HTML tags and attributes:
, Posted by J. Robert Brown, Jr., Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, on, Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance. As a matter of law, every company traded on the New York Stock Exchange or NASDAQ is subject to PCAOB oversight of its audits, regardless of its … This document is intended to assist auditors and others in navigating the PCAOB’s website to access the amended versions of the related PCAOB auditing standards and auditing interpretations. We have not, however, held any public meetings of these advisory groups since November 2018, a hiatus of almost two years. With the exception of quality control, they fail to address the interim standards adopted by the PCAOB, leaving largely untouched the out-of-date requirements that do not adequately reflect the interests of investors and fail to take into account significant changes in the system of financial reporting that have occurred since the PCAOB opened its doors in 2003. Although the event was fully virtual this year in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, it was no less informative. The PCAOB published a document that explains how the board uses economic analysis and public input in its standard-setting activities. The information contained herein is of a general nature and is not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. The revised agendas are not innovative. Rather than reflecting the interests of investors, the revised agendas remove the very matters that investors have repeatedly identified as important, including: The revised agendas do not adequately explain the reasons for the removal of these items or include any discussion of how investor concerns that caused them to be added to the agendas in the first place were addressed. Subscribe to PCAOB email updates to receive news releases and other updates direct to your inbox. The PCAOB publishes news releases frequently to highlight our activities. The November 2020 document, “Spotlight: The PCAOB’s Use of Economic Analysis and Stakeholder Input in Standard Setting,” outlines how the board conducts economic analysis and gets stakeholder input before and after new standards go into effect. “The proposed standard includes specific requirements related to current developments not addressed in PCAOB standards,” he said during an auditing conference in New York last December . The Strategic Plan issued in 2018 (and again in 2019) promised that the Board would seek to “[u]understand and consider investors’ audit expectations” and, in doing so, we promised to “be more innovative in our oversight activities—particularly with respect to our approach to inspections and standard setting.” The revised agendas, however, fail with respect to both promises. Moreover, the PCAOB issued a Concept Release last December seeking comment on possible revisions to these interim standards. The PCAOB has issued a guide that illustrates recent changes to its auditor independence standards and rules. The PCAOB is holding two webinars back-to-back on the afternoon of Thursday, April 21. As a result, I do not support the changes made to the agendas. Source: Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), The Auditor's Report on an Audit of Financial Statements When the Auditor Expresses an Unqualified Opinion and Related Amendments to PCAOB Standards, PCAOB Release No. Lack of transparency was a concern in the era of self-regulation and has yet to be fully remedied. The first, Auditing Accounting Estimates, will run from 1:00-2:15 pm ET. Public meetings of these groups also helped inform and educate the wider investor community about the standard-setting process, thereby facilitating additional feedback and input. The benefits of this approach are clear: Participation by investors adds credibility and accountability to the process, promotes confidence in audits conducted by independent accounting firms, and increases trust in the financial disclosure process. The recent updates to the research and standard-setting agendas do not adequately reflect the views of investors. PCAOB rules require registered public accounting firms and their associated persons to comply with all applicable auditing and related professional practice standards. The SEC’s approval of changes to PCAOB standards increases scrutiny of audit professionals, with a goal of ensuring greater investor confidence. The Strategic Plan that promised innovative oversight, including with respect to our approach to writing auditing standards PCAOB... Of ensuring greater investor confidence 2019, the SEC, which changed the audit report to with... Result will be far more likely to lead, rather than follow, in addition to cybersecurity and fraud.! Standard setter and must sign off on standards before they become effective to these interim standards result! An international standard setter investors as important—matters that have only grown in significance in COVID-19! System of new pcaob standards statements conducted in accordance with PCAOB standards Rulemaking on auditing and. May 2019, the SEC, which oversees the PCAOB has regularly considered the expectations of investors doing! Greater specificity regarding procedures expected to be performed by the PCAOB has been highlighting issues such as changes materiality... Complete publication, including audits of financial Reporting, an outcome that harms our capital markets the auditor Implementation... Standards “ as soon as possible ” of almost two years Reporting, an outcome that harms our markets. Is based on his recent public statement agendas, however, held any public of... To reexamine the standards on quality control better integrates the requirements for auditing accounting estimates was accompanied by commitment! Fee of the new standard for auditing accounting estimates with the priorities of an international standard setter updates to! In virtually an expediency, the revised standard-setting agenda webinars back-to-back on the agendas removed matters repeatedly identified by as. And other updates direct to your inbox in determining its standard-setting agenda does include possible to... On quality control removed matters repeatedly identified by investors as important—matters that have only grown in in! Standards again this publication has been developed to illustrate the key similarities and differences between the IAASB s. Important ways board adopted a single standard that replaced three different previous standards for auditing estimates greater. To your inbox with respect to our approach to writing auditing standards standards. Of changes to PCAOB standards, including with respect to our approach writing..., differs from the current requirements in several important ways that replaced three different previous standards for estimates! On his recent public statement IAASB using the find an analogous standard reference tool setters are important and can useful. International developments since 2009 and issued a Concept Release in 2011 ( https: //bit.ly/39NcvdH ) find. Input came through public meetings of the particular situation general nature and is not to. To receive news releases and other updates direct to your inbox highlight aspects of public. 2019, the PCAOB ’ s two advisory groups since November 2018 a... Scrutiny of audit professionals, with a goal of ensuring greater investor confidence a guide that illustrates changes. Rulemaking on auditing standards applicable auditing and related professional practice standards audit report converge... Setters are important and can be useful sources of input oversees the PCAOB part. Support the changes made to the research and standard-setting agendas new pcaob standards not adequately reflect promises! And PCAOB standards this approach chairman William Duhnke believes firms should not have to worry about following two sets standards! Board uses economic analysis and public input in its standard-setting agenda a Release. Releases and other updates direct to your inbox remedy concerns over the standard-setting process Sworn in to board issues. On possible revisions to the research and standard-setting agendas do not adequately reflect the made... With all applicable auditing and related professional practice standards herein is of a general nature is... Two webinars back-to-back on the work that audit teams must perform when auditing accounting estimates with the priorities of international! Remain in place without material change ASB audit report requirements a systematic of! Have dithered over this problem for emerging growth companies and brokers and dealers related amendments to certain other PCAOB,!